Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
The Beatles vs One Direction: Which do you think hit America harder?
#1
I have heard that some people believe that the Brittish boy band One Direction has hit America harder than Beatlemania.
I love The Beatles and I will listen to One Direction on a few occasions. But I personally don't believe that they hit harder than The Beatles. I mean, yeah they have had a pretty big crowd waiting for them in almost all of their concerts, but I don't think they are as big as The Beatles.

I really want your opinions, guys.
Do you agree? Disagree? Can't decide?

I check the site twice a day, five days a week. Drop a line, reply to the thread!
When we sing, we want the world to hear us.
When we play, we want the world to watch.
When we dance, we want the world to know us.
We sing, we dance, we steal things.
Human; that is all we ever are.
Reply
#2
I bearly know who 1 direction is Smile but maybe they didn't have good promotion in Romania. But think about it this way, if the Beatles had the promotion means available today they would have had even more succes than they did so I'd say The Beatles win. I don't even want to start talking about their importance in music history.

I'm cheering for Arctic Monkeys!
Reply
#3
THE BEATLES !!!!!!!!

Here we go again!!!....The Bay City Rollers, in the Scottish kilts, and the Beatle sound alike Canadian band Klaatu were tagged as the next Beatles! How far did they go?

No one even comes close!
 The ultimate connection is between a performer and its' audience!
Reply
#4
lmao
that's all I can come up with

Reply
#5
Music Head Wrote:lmao
that's all I can come up with

another classic MH comment!!!!, so simple,yet effective and spot on!
"BTO....Bachman,Turner,Overweight
They were big in the 70s....for five minutes,on a Saturday,after lunch..."  -  Me 2014.


Reply
#6
gotta luv the Music Head !!!!..lol
 The ultimate connection is between a performer and its' audience!
Reply
#7
You guys are too funny! I love all the replys!
And I will agree with you Ioana, if advertisements are a big must in the musical world, but I am sure that it will get too you one day soon. Hahahah.
When we sing, we want the world to hear us.
When we play, we want the world to watch.
When we dance, we want the world to know us.
We sing, we dance, we steal things.
Human; that is all we ever are.
Reply
#8
The Beatles definitely hit America harder. When you look at how big singles were in the 1960s there were tens of millions of young people buying them. Also the Beatles made a huge impression when the media then was a fraction of what it is now ie the internet, digital TV stations, digital radio, internet radio etc.
Reply
#9
PlattHillSpirit Wrote:The Beatles definitely hit America harder. When you look at how big singles were in the 1960s there were tens of millions of young people buying them. Also the Beatles made a huge impression when the media then was a fraction of what it is now ie the internet, digital TV stations, digital radio, internet radio etc.


You make a very valid point, would you agree that-because of media- that The Beatles got even popular?
When we sing, we want the world to hear us.
When we play, we want the world to watch.
When we dance, we want the world to know us.
We sing, we dance, we steal things.
Human; that is all we ever are.
Reply
#10
If it weren't for The Beatles there would be no One Direction. John, Paul, George, and Ringo started a revolution that still in the hearts and minds of music lovers today. Their music still catches the ear of today's generation. Basically their music is timeless. I feel that One Direction will not last nearly as long as The Beatles, nor will they make as big of an impact on the music industry.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  NEW SINGLE: Beatles - "now and then" CRAZY-HORSE 5 1,577 16-11-2023, 12:23
Last Post: Music Head
  NEW RE-ISSUE: Beatles "revolver" CRAZY-HORSE 0 791 02-11-2022, 07:46
Last Post: CRAZY-HORSE
  NEW VIDEO: Beatles "here comes the sun" CRAZY-HORSE 4 1,845 30-09-2019, 09:36
Last Post: CRAZY-HORSE
  RE-ISSUE ALBUM: The Beatles "the beatles" CRAZY-HORSE 0 1,149 25-11-2018, 13:48
Last Post: CRAZY-HORSE
  The Beatles influence lives on SilverBeat 6 3,051 25-02-2017, 03:00
Last Post: SteveO
  Beatles songwriting infographic NatStringer 3 2,459 13-11-2016, 21:01
Last Post: MissNSporty
  See rare color photos of The Beatles on The Ed Sullivan Show! Mercury7 0 1,266 13-02-2016, 16:47
Last Post: Mercury7
  Stone-cold Classical pros do the Beatles jazzboCR 1 1,246 08-07-2015, 23:06
Last Post: SteveO
  Songs the Beatles gave away jazzboCR 4 1,799 04-01-2015, 22:17
Last Post: jazzboCR
  Beatles Revolver radio discussion Mrrusty1 0 847 20-11-2014, 12:18
Last Post: Mrrusty1

Forum Jump: