Playlist Opinions Please

[FactoryMadeTeddy]

1. Our Swords - Band of Horses
2. Young Folks - Peter Bjorn and John
3. Keep Fishin' - Weezer
4. Tired of Sex - Weezer
5. Olde Tyme Mem'ry - Erik Petersen
6. Every Town will Celebrate - Erik Petersen
7. Basketcase - Green Day
8. In The Morning - The Coral
9. 80 Windows - Nada Surf
10. Do It Again - Nada Surf
11. Train in Vain (Stand By Me) - The Clash
12. When The Party Ends - Saturday Looks Good to Me
13. Fake Plastic Trees - Radiohead
14. Karma Police - Radiohead
15. Dreaming Of You - The Coral
16. Hold Me - Weezer
17. Polite Dance Song - The Bird & The Bee
18. Say it Ain't So - Weezer
19. When I come around - Green Day
20. Things I don't Remember - Ugly Casanova
21. Dramamine - Modest Mouse

Please tell me what you think of this mixed CD I made for my car, I'm a bit old school, I know...

If you feel like there's a song I should replace with an even better one, do tell.

Thank You

PS. Hello, I'm Liz. I'm 20 years old and I have listed some of my favourite songs just now, if you 'd like to get to know me as I'm new here.

[Tiggi]

Ooh !! Goody, a poll...

Hi Liz, & welcome to Music Discussion.

Unfortunately I'm unfamiliar with about half the stuff on your playlist, so am perhaps not best placed to pass judgement. That's not going to stop me from voting, though, and my vote is going to be a fence-sitter.

Of the music that I know, most is OK, so that's how I've voted.

It'll be interesting to see how this turns out...

[Iota]

Everything but Radiohead is crap. In fact, those aren't the best Radiohead songs either.

Not all that great...

[CMB1888]

You indy sindy!

Not exactly my sort of thing but I do like that Coral track

(but I don't like Radiohead)

Hello and welcome

[underclass hero]

i liked the stuff by weezer and greenday cause im a teenager like radiohead but none of the songs you had same with modest mouse

[JonG]

If it was me I'd want more variety - no two songs by the same artist. The songs do seem to work together. I think they have similar sounds but because I'm not familiar with all of the songs I don't know if the sequencing can be improved upon.

I personally find most of those bands only okay and a few I don't like at all (Greenday). I do not have suggestions as to what to substitute. I'm in favor of scrapping most all of them.

That being said if they're your favorites, and this is a playlist for you to listen to in your car, then what matters is it pleases you. Why do you need/want our opinions?

[underclass hero]

how can u not like greenday the band that started pop punk!!!! every one knows its the best genre ever made (in my opinion)

[JonG]

how can u not like greenday the band that started pop punk!!!!

I think you know that's not true just from hanging out here. If you truly do not, listen to the Buzzcocks's Singles Going Steady collection.

[underclass hero]

dont really look at the buzzcocks as "pop punk" more hardcore to me

[Iota]

Okay, since Buzzcocks are 'hardcore': Greenday started Pop Punk? Hüsker Dü's Flip your Wig was released two years before Greenday was founded and All's Allroy's Sez was released two years before Greenday released their first album. Go figure.