+- Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com)
+-- Forum: Music Discussion (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Rock/Classic Rock/Prog Rock/Blues (https://www.music-discussion.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+--- Thread: Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist (/showthread.php?tid=2429)
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - kvincent5555 - 01-01-2010
Just opinions, of course, but could get interesting...
Queen:
Underrated: Keep Yourself Alive
Overrated: Crazy Little Thing
Bowie:
U: Queen Bitch
O: Changes
Who:
U: Quadrophenia
O: Who's Next
Sabbath:
U: Supernaut
O: Iron Man
Zep:
U: III
O: II
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - gryphon - 01-01-2010
Overrated: Rudebox...............Robbie Williams
Underrated: Home Thoughts From Abroad ..........Clifford T. Ward
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - Jerome - 01-02-2011
Who's Next - overrrated!!! Not in a million years. It's their best album by far.
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - CRAZY-HORSE - 01-02-2011
overrated: Justin Bieber
underrated: Small Faces
overrated: Dark Side Of The Moon-PF
underrated: The Final Cut-PF
overrated: Pet Sounds-Beach Boys
underrated:Back To The Egg-Wings
overrated: Harvest-Neil Young
underrated: The Style Council
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - Jerome - 02-02-2011
CH this is sacrilge. DSOTM was in the charts for over 700 weeks!!!! Agree about TFC though - think it's absolutely brilliant. Some very clever writing on that album, both musically and lyrically. By the way, Uncle Neil himself has said that 'Harvest' was his finest hour.
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - CRAZY-HORSE - 02-02-2011
Jerome Wrote:CH this is sacrilge. DSOTM was in the charts for over 700 weeks!!!! Agree about TFC though - think it's absolutely brilliant. Some very clever writing on that album, both musically and lyrically. By the way, Uncle Neil himself has said that 'Harvest' was his finest hour.
sorry Jerome, but i dont see what all the hoopla is with DSOTM,its a good album but i just dont think its worth all the praise it gets... i prefer The Wall, The Final Cut and Division Bell....i'll let you know what i think of WYWH when it arrives.
Harvest...well i have all of NY's albums(inc. Springfields,CSNY, and Stills Young Band) except "time fades away", which is yet to be released on cd, and near impossible to find on vinyl,....i dunno, i just think Harvest Moon,After The Goldrush,Everybody Knows..., and Prairie Wind
contain superior songs
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - Jerome - 03-02-2011
I particulary like CS&N's 'Daylight Again'. (slightly off the subject but had to get that in)
Underrated and overrated songs/albums by famous or favorite artist - CRAZY-HORSE - 04-02-2011
back to the subject at hand:
overrated: Oasis
underrated: Neil & Tim Finn
overrated: The Stones
underrated: Small Faces
overrated: A Night At The Opera-Queen
underrated: The Game-Queen