Not sure if this is the super correct forum for this (it's argueable what genre, rock or alt/indie)
But I love Brand New. They are like my favorite band. Ever since they I heard them from my Alaskan roomate freshman year (over 5 years ago). I loved their freshman release of Your Favorite Weapon and it's crying about your girlfriend leaving you style.
Deja Entendu took a while for me to really appreciate due to the big difference, but now it's my favorite. The Devil and God album also took time but it's tied with YFW for second.
I love them to death but everyone I show them to doesn't like it or thinks they're just ok.... What gives?